The new plans are out, and Open Enrollment is upon us! People who have been enrolled in Marketplace plans in the past may be getting notices offering for them to auto-renew their plans. That sounds easy, but it may not be in your best (financial, or health coverage) interests!
First, a plan may sound the same, but providers may decide to affiliate or disaffiliate from year to year. So you always to want to make sure that your doctors take your health insurance.
The plans that are offered may change also. For instance, in Washtenaw County in 2019, there will be a new health insurance provider—Oscar—that has not previously been in the Michigan health insurance market. And even without that new insurer, some insurers may decide to charge less or more for their plans.
The pricing of these plans matters, because tax credits are based on the actual cost of the second lowest silver plan. That is the benchmark from which all tax credits get calculated.
Let’s say that your income is exactly the same between 2018 and 2019, and you qualify for tax credits. If you auto-renew, you could find yourself paying a whole lot more. Even if the plan has not changed, and the full cost of the plan doesn’t have a big difference, there could still be a big difference in tax credits.
In this case, in 2018 the Pacesetter A plan was the lowest-cost plan, and in 2019 it is the third-lowest-cost plan. Even though the full cost of the plan only went up by $20, the subsidized cost went up a lot more. In this example, for the same exact plan, and with the same exact income, you could end up paying $70 more per month ($840 more per year), more than double what you paid the year before!